Best eyeliner known to man. Precision is great, after awhile the tip frays but its usually at the end of the liners life. Color is black and beautiful. Waterproof and hard to remove. Applys amazing. Ive gone swimming in this. Causes zero eye irritation but your eyes need to be dry for this product to word.

I’m an older gal with crepey, hooded eyelids. I’ve used Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner for decades. It requires a brush and is expensive $37. It drys up fairly quickly. Sooo I gave this a try. Oh. My. Gosh! Very easy to apply, stays put and doesn’t bother my very sensitive eyes. I will by again and highly recommend this product!

I've been repurchasing the NYX Epic Ink Liner for a while now and it's honestly become one of my holy grail makeup products. The formula lasts really well throughout the day, dries fast, doesn't smudge easily, and the brush tip makes it super precise and easy to apply, even when doing thinner lines or winged liner. I've also experienced no eye irritation from this product.

This was my first time trying the brown instead of the black, and while I will say it's not quite as intensely pigmented as the black version, I honestly expected that from a brown liner anyway. I actually really like the softer look it gives. I have green/hazel eyes and feel like the brown color complements them without looking too harsh. I love using it with softer glam makeup looks!

I think this is an amazing affordable eyeliner and performs just as well as a lot of higher-end brands that I've tried.

I’ve been on the hunt for a dark brown liquid eyeliner from the drugstore I was nervous ordering this shade as I think it’s going to be like many other browns I’ve bought that aren’t black but not dark enough for what I like.

This is it! In the pic I compare both nyx black & the dark chocolate. The color fits the bill for what I’ve been looking for.

I always keep it upside down so it doesn’t dry out. I do like the tip gives a smooth application. Also it last all day but when I want to remove it, it easily wipes off w micellar or face wash.

The color is great if you don’t want the harshness of black but isn’t too light for my brown eyes. It’s great for night as well again because it’s not too light. It’s truly DARK chocolate.

I think it compliments lighter eyes as well.

This is a repeat buy for me.

I absolutely live with eyeliner on every single moment of the day. However, I have very oily eyelids and majority of eyeliners fail to last or stay put on my lids. So I require a very waterproof and smudgeproof formula to at least look good majority of the day before my oils decide to ruin it.

My preferences for my eyeliners are a opaque black with a brush tip. As opaque and fluid felt tip eyeliners are, they are hard to control around my hooded eyes and sometimes end up becoming dried out even though I've only used the eyeliner a couple times.

I've compared this NYX eyeliner against some of my favorites or some well known brands: Maybelline's Hyper Easy, MACQUEEN's Waterproof, EM Cosmetic's Illustrative, Heroine Make Smooth Liquid, Eyeko Black Magic, and KVD's Tattoo Liner.

I put each of these up against 4 tests, which I've illustrated in my pictures. Maybelline's new eyeliner held up moderately well, and it's the only formula I've ever found to dry down matte and be this resistant. Of course, my favorite Asian eyeliners from MACQUEEN and Heroine Make are super waterproof and budget roof. Eyeko is also a favorite Asian brand that lasts moderately well. EM Cosmetics did not claim to be waterproof, just resistant, so I've allowed that to slide. I've never liked KVD's formula for my lids, so I'm not surprised that it didn't last.

In comparison to those, NYX's formula isn't horrible and would work beautifully for most people, but it definitely can't last through my mighty eyelids. HOWEVER, I absolutely love how opaque the formula is in one swipe and how fluid and even it is. Makes it really easy to do graphic liners! It is also great for creating quick and easy wings (with a precise hand of course since it's so pigmented).

I am going to continue using this with a primer or powder because I am enjoying the pigment! If you don't have crazy oily eyelids and would love a dark and even application with a brush tip eyeliner, I would highly recommend this eyeliner! And even if you do have lids like me, I'm sure one could make it work with some preparation!

This eyeliner is fantastic. The brush tip makes it easy to create both thin, precise lines and bolder looks, giving excellent control during application. The formula goes on smoothly with rich black color and dries quickly.

It lasts throughout the day without smudging and holds up well even in humid conditions. The waterproof formula performs exactly as expected while still being comfortable to wear.

Overall, this is a high-quality eyeliner that delivers great results at an excellent price. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a reliable liquid eyeliner.

Happy enough with how it applies and stays on. Doesn’t pill or lift up (too bad, it’s a little watery at times if you go over one spot too much) when applying in layers, which is what most of my other brush tip eyeliners do and what prompted me to look for a new one. I think the fine hair brush tip versus an entirely felt tip is what improves the functionality and flow of this one.

The brush itself isn’t too tiny like other liquid liners, but the line it makes is very thin, to the point where if my hand twitches even a little, it picks up every movement lol. Not complaining at all ab that though. I got the milk chocolate color. This is after 8 hours of wear. It comes off super easy with a makeup wipe too. Haven’t tested the waterproof (ness?) but I did sweat some that day. This will 100% be my new go to liner.

★★★☆☆

I had high hopes for this because everyone raves about it, and honestly... it's not bad. The pigment is amazing, it's probably the juiciest eyeliner pen I've ever used, and it glides on effortlessly.

BUT...

It claims to be waterproof, and that's where it loses points for me.

Once it's dry, it's pretty smudge-resistant for everyday wear. If I leave it alone, it stays put. But I specifically bought it because I have watery eyes and I swim, so I put the "waterproof" claim to the test.

The second water got involved, it started breaking down way faster than I expected. Even after it was completely dry, rubbing it with my finger made it disappear pretty easily. Maybe I rubbed harder than the average person would, but if you're advertising waterproof, I'm going to test it like it's waterproof.

For normal daily makeup? It's great.

For swimming, crying, or anything involving a lot of water? I'd skip it.

I'd honestly give it about 3.5/5 stars if I could. Great eyeliner, just not as waterproof as it's advertised to be.

Ótimo produto, realmente é à prova d'água, não borrou no calor do verão em São Paulo! Demorou a chegar porque veio da Holanda, mas o prazo foi informado e chegou no último dia do prazo. Recomendo.

Es original y estaba en una excelente oferta, el color es muy vibrante y dura mucho, es a prueba de agua.

This is as good as the Tom Ford liquid liner!! As my eye lids became softer with age and very hard to make a smooth line of liner I always looked for the best one to use so have been using the Tom Ford liquid liner for last 4/5 years and have kept on looking for another one as the Tom Ford one is very expensive. Ultimately I found this one almost as good as the Tom Ford liner. ❤️

I love this brown eyeliner! The shade is rich and natural, perfect for everyday wear.

Per me è uno degli eyeliner migliori mai provati! Lo utilizzo tutti i giorni e dura davvero tantissimo tant’è che lo ricompro ogni 6 mesi. È molto pigmentato e il pennellino ha la punta sottile perciò si riesce ad essere molto precisi e fare delle linee perfette! Non sbava, se si vuole togliere qualche eccesso, basta usare un cottonfioc imbevuto nello struccante per il viso. Lo uso anche quando vado al mare i in piscina e non ho mai avuto problemi. Lo utilizzo addirittura per riempire spazi tra i peletti delle sopracciglia insieme all’eye-liner marrone utilizzando la tecnica pelo a pelo. Certo, bisogna avere la mano per farlo ma per chi ha dimestichezza lo stra consiglio!!!